Gay United Methodist pastor in Clifton on trial – again

Mark Curnutte
Cincinnati Enquirer
The Rev. David Meredith (right) and his husband, Jim Schlachter, at their home in Madeira.

An openly gay Clifton minister who withstood one effort to push him out of the United Methodist Church is now being subjected to another challenge from within the denomination.

The Rev. David Meredith, 61, exonerated in October of two of three charges brought against him in a local church court, will face another hearing Friday in a regional Methodist court in Indianapolis.

Take the news with you. Download the Cincinnati.com app.

He will appear before the North Central Jurisdictional Committee on Appeals. That internal Methodist court is larger than the first and has authority on denominational matters in the upper Midwest.

"There's a mean-spiritedness to it," said Meredith, the popular pastor of Clifton United Methodist Church since July 2012. "They refuse to let me and other gay and lesbian clergy and our communities simply be in the church."

The appeals process will either affirm the decision made in October by the Committee on Investigation of the West Ohio Conference of the United Methodist Church or tell that body to reconsider the three charges brought against Meredith.

The West Ohio Conference committee did not certify charges against Meredith for being a "self-avowed practicing homosexual" or for immorality. A charge of disobedience, however, was certified. That latter charge relates to a rule in the 2012 edition of the United Methodist Book of Discipline: "Ceremonies that celebrate homosexual unions shall not be conducted by our ministers and shall not be conducted in our churches."

The new hearing has come about as an appeal of the lower-church court ruling.

The counsel for the church, a formal position that functions as counsel for the original 10 complainants against Meredith, is the Rev. Gregory Stover, the retired pastor of Armstrong Chapel United Methodist Church in Indian Hill. Stover decided to make the appeal to a higher church court after conferring with the complainants.

Reached through the West Ohio Conference office in Columbus, Stover declined to comment on a pending case.

Meredith said he and Stover know each other and that their roles in the decades-old denominational battle over homosexuality are not personal.

"He and I have been called upon to represent two very different viewpoints of Methodism in this region," Meredith said.

The group fighting Meredith includes two prominent Greater Cincinnati Methodist pastors – the Rev. Mark Rowland, the senior pastor of Anderson Hills United Methodist Church, Anderson Township; and the Rev. Derek Russell of Hillsboro First United Methodist Church.

Meredith and his partner of almost 29 years, Jim Schlachter, were married on May 7, 2016. Two days after the wedding ceremony, the first complaints about Meredith's sexual orientation as a Methodist minister were filed with the West Ohio Conference.

Three days after Meredith and Schlacter were married, the denomination's international voting body met in Portland, Oregon, to consider changing church doctrine on homosexuality. Church leaders did not address the issue but voted instead to send it to a committee.

In 2008 and 2012 the United Methodist Church voted against removing anti-gay policies, the core of which read that homosexuality is "incompatible with Christian teaching."

A special session to address homosexuality is planned by Methodist leaders for February 2019 in St. Louis.

In the meantime, Meredith carries on. He and the overall idea of embracing a gay clergy have wide support within the denomination nationally. Meredith and leaders of the Affirm Inclusion and Reconciling Ministries Network will hold a news conference Thursday in Indianapolis. On Friday, beginning at 9:45 a.m. outside of the Hilton Indianapolis, 120 W. Market St., a prayerful rally will be held to support Meredith.

"There has been a bright side to this coin," Meredith said. "The longer we can keep the issue in the public eye and keep talking about it, the better. Every year that passes also moves me another year closer to retirement."